The Hollywood Reporter Article, March 18, 1999
Film review- St. Patrick's
Day
By David Hunter
From John Huston's "The Dead" to Thomas Vinterberg's "The Celebration,"
large family gatherings on special occasions have been potent subject matter in the
hands of an accomplished moviemaker. While rookie writer-director Hope Perello is
a little woozy in her direction, the low-budget U.S. indie "St. Patrick's Day"
is a satisfying mix of comedy and drama with excellent performances by headliners
Piper Laurie and Joanne Baron.
St. Patrick's Day the holiday, the tradition,
is a time for singing and wailing, lovemaking and fighting, drinking and praying.
These activities and more occur in Perello's mostly gentle, civilized film that has
no shocking family secrets as in Huston and Vinterberg's more ambitious but gloomier
films. But the payoffs in "St. Patrick's Day" are well worth spending 105
minutes with the Donnellys and McDonoughs, Irish-Americans who are not far removed
from the immigrant experience. Life has been good to the dozen or so characters in
the film, but in the tradition of such scenarios, many big and little crises and
epiphanies occur.
Perello opts for matter-of-fact portraits of individuals, their
talents and failings, with some wonderfully intimate moments and singing performances.
Second cousins surrender to their lustful desires, a married couple of 15 years annouce
their pending divorce, the matriarch of the family declares at the start of dinner
that she has taken the "pledge" and forbids any drinking of alcohol, an
unpopular but cheerfully honored restriction that is eventually resolved in favor
of the imbibers.
Perello keeps the pace moving along nicely but allows the actors
to have many unhurried moments where their characters come into focus. The most endearing
and satisfying story line relates the long overdue coming together of widow Pat (Laurie)
and gentlemanly Thomas (Redmond M. Gleeson), great friends who in an exquisitely
filmed scene, the film's best, become great lovers. Both actors are thoroughly engaging
in their roles thanks more to Perello's writing than often too-conservative directing.
Baron is likewise terrific as Mary Pat's daughter, who is in the middle of breaking
up with her husband (Jim Metzler). He delivers a heart-felt and eloquent farewell
to the assembled family in another splendid scene.
Working out the story's constraints
of time and locale, Perello gets the job done nicely. The all-around superb cast
includes David Ault, Herta Ware and Colleen Fitzpatrick.
The article is accompanied
by a small black and white photo of Piper Lauie holding Joanne Baron- Here's a
toast to the talent of Piper Laurie, top, and Joanne Baron.